AUS PROPERTY REPORT logo

Victoria's Proposed Mandatory Vendor Building Report Scheme: The Bigger Issue Is Inspector Quality and Consumer Protection

general

The Victorian Government's proposed mandatory vendor building report scheme has sparked significant discussion across the property industry.

Under the proposal, sellers would be required to organise a building and pest inspection before listing their property for sale, with the report then made available to prospective buyers.

The reform is being promoted as a way to:

  • Reduce duplicated inspection costs,
  • Improve transparency,
  • Help buyers make more informed decisions before purchasing property.

At face value, those goals are understandable.

Many Victorian buyers currently spend thousands of dollars on multiple building inspections while unsuccessfully bidding at auction or missing out on homes.

But while much of the public discussion has focused on who pays for the report, there is a far more important issue that still remains unresolved:

Who is actually qualified to produce the report in the first place?


Victoria's Proposal Is Not New

Victoria's proposed model is heavily based on the ACT system, which has operated since 2003 under the Civil Law (Sale of Residential Property) Act 2003.

Under the ACT framework:

  • Vendors organise the inspection,
  • The report is provided before sale,
  • Buyers can still choose to obtain their own independent inspection if they wish.

Importantly, the ACT experience highlights something buyers and regulators should pay close attention to:

When buyers increasingly rely on vendor-provided reports, the competency, thoroughness and independence of the inspector becomes even more important.

Industry participants within the ACT property market openly acknowledge that inspection quality can vary significantly depending on which inspection company is engaged. Some agencies are known for using highly thorough inspectors, while others may prioritise lower-cost providers producing more limited reporting.

That creates a major consumer protection issue if buyers begin relying heavily on vendor-provided reports as their primary due diligence document.


The Real Problem: There Is Still No Dedicated Licensing System in Victoria

One of the biggest misconceptions among consumers is that all pre-purchase building inspectors are heavily regulated or licensed.

In Victoria, that is not currently the case.

Unlike electricians, plumbers or registered builders, there is no dedicated standalone licensing system specifically for pre-purchase building inspectors.

This means consumers can struggle to assess:

  • An inspector's competency,
  • Practical construction experience,
  • Report quality,
  • Inspection methodology,
  • Or professional standards.

Some inspectors have decades of relevant building experience and produce highly detailed reports.

Others may have minimal practical building background or nothing at all and operate with very different standards.

That inconsistency becomes significantly more important in a vendor-report model where buyers may place substantial reliance on a single report commissioned before sale.


A Vendor Report Is Only as Good as the Inspector Behind It

The debate should not simply be:

"Should the seller pay for the report?"

The more important question is:

"How do consumers know the report itself is competent, thorough and independent?"

A mandatory vendor report system does not automatically guarantee:

  • Better inspections,
  • Better consumer outcomes,
  • Better protection for buyers.

If anything, increasing reliance on pre-sale reports may place even greater importance on:

  • Inspector competency,
  • Meaningful verification,
  • Minimum experience requirements,
  • Professional indemnity insurance,
  • Consistent reporting standards.

Without strong standards, there is a real risk that report quality becomes inconsistent across the market.


Why Some Buyers Will Still Want Their Own Independent Inspection

Even if Victoria introduces mandatory vendor reports, some buyers will still choose to obtain their own independent inspection.

That decision is not necessarily because every vendor report is unreliable.

It is because:

  • Buyers may want their own inspector working directly for them,
  • They may want additional guidance or verbal advice,
  • They may want specific concerns investigated,
  • They may simply want confidence in the person carrying out the inspection.

This is especially relevant in Melbourne's auction market, where buyers often make unconditional purchasing decisions under significant time pressure.

For many buyers, an independent inspection remains one of the few opportunities to obtain direct professional advice before becoming legally committed to the largest purchase of their life.


The Focus Should Be on Consumer Protection, Not Just Cost Reduction

Reducing duplicated inspection costs is a worthwhile discussion.

But cost reduction alone should not become the primary measure of success.

If Victoria considers proceeding with a vendor-report system, the focus should include:

  • Meaningful minimum competency standards for inspectors,
  • Inspector verification,
  • Transparent qualifications and experience,
  • Proper insurance requirements,
  • Report quality expectations,
  • Genuine consumer protections.

Otherwise, the industry risks creating a system where consumers place heavy reliance on reports without fully understanding the variability that can exist between inspectors.


What APR Believes

We believe consumers deserve:

  • Transparency,
  • Independent information,
  • And confidence in the competency of the person inspecting the property.

"The long-term solution is lifting the standards across the building inspection industry from zero to one."

That means:

  • Better verification,
  • Minimum competency standards,
  • Stronger consumer education,
  • And clearer accountability around who is competent to carry out pre-purchase inspections.

Because ultimately, a building report is only as valuable as the knowledge, experience and integrity of the inspector preparing it.

Tags

victoriaVendor Building Report Scheme